Pastors of St. Joseph
| 1860-1896 | Preists shared with St. Aloysius |
| 1896-1902 | Rev. Anthony Runnebaum |
| 1902-1911 | Rev. Henry Schengber |
| 1911 | Rev. Joseph Sieber |
| 1911 | Rev. John Dickhaus |
| 1911-1912 | Rev.William Spickerman |
| 1913 | Rev. George Meyerhoefer |
| 1913 | Rev. John Meyerhoefer |
| 1913-1914 | Rev. Andrew Hammersbach |
| 1914-1919 | Rev. William J. Spickerman |
| 1919-1924 | Rev. Francis A. Reardon |
| 1924-1926 | Rev. Charles O'Leary |
| 1926-1933 | Rev. Clarence Graf |
| 1933-1946 | Rev. Lawrence Meyer |
| 1946-1953 | Rev. Henry Ausdenmoore |
| 1953-1962 | Rev. Robert Leugers |
| 1962-1971 | Rev. Edward Lawler |
| 1971-1974 | Rev. Basil Haneberg |
| 1974-1983 | Rev. John Jennings |
| 1983-1994 | Rev. Donald Tenoever |
| 1994-2003 | Rev. Harry Gerdes |
| 2003- | Rev. Michael Savino |